Hello dear
Welcome To Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Cape May
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Cape May shines as a local gem, offering a delightful selection of delicious pizzas and hearty Italian favorites. Located conveniently on NJ-109, this eatery has garnered rave reviews for its extraordinary mozzarella sticks and robust marinara sauce. Diners rave about the fresh ingredients, exemplified by the highly praised Greek salad. The warm atmosphere and friendly service create a welcoming environment for families, though takeout and delivery options are highly recommended for the best experience. With crispy crusts and mouthwatering pasta dishes, Tony's remains a must-visit culinary destination for pizza lovers and more.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Ham And Cheese
US$10.95Chocolate Cake
US$4.25Greek Salad
US$11.50
Tossed Garden Salad
US$6.75Chicken Francaise
US$19.50Veal Francaise
US$21.95
Veal Marsala
US$21.95Chicken Marsala
US$19.50Eggplant Parmigiana
US$19.50 About
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Cape May
Welcome to Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Cape May, a beloved gem nestled at 1216 NJ-109 in the charming coastal town of Cape May, New Jersey. This establishment is more than just a pizzeria; it embodies warmth, community, and a passion for delicious food. As you step inside—or opt for takeout—you'll find a menu filled with mouthwatering offerings sure to satisfy any craving.
Known for its incredible pizza, Tony's has earned the title of the favorite pizza spot among locals and visitors alike. Customers rave about the 'perfect cheese and crispy crust', creating an ideal balance in every bite. But the highlights don't stop there; Tony's is also famous for its mozzarella sticks, praised by one enthusiastic customer as 'the absolute best in the entire world.' Pair these cheesy delights with their robust marinara sauce, and you're in for a treat!
The menu also showcases a diverse selection of dishes beyond pizza. Families have enjoyed stellar Stromboli and fresh Greek salads that leave even the pickiest eaters satisfied—one little diner couldn't get enough of the greens! For those looking for something a bit more indulgent, the creamy pasta Alfredo adds a rich touch to the experience, rounding out what many consider a well-crafted menu.
What sets Tony's apart is not just the food but the experience. Customers repeatedly mention the friendly, welcoming atmosphere, particularly during quieter off-season visits. Whether you're dining in or enjoying a cozy meal at home, the staff at Tony's Pizzeria make you feel right at home, always ready to help with a smile. Even those who have arrived near closing time have left fulfilled and grateful, having been treated with kindness and served delicious meals.
In a town where quality dining can sometimes be overshadowed by tourist spots, Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Cape May stands out for its commitment to delicious food at reasonable prices. The accolades are numerous, and the satisfied smiles tell the full story. So, whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Tony's—your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Our favorite pizza in Cape May! And my absolute favorite mozzarella sticks in the entire world (I am not kidding 10/10!) Their marinara sauce is solid and they also make a great meatball. I can only really recommend takeout or delivery, not the best atmosphere for sitdown dinner. ”
“ We came in on a slow, off-season, Monday night with our family. The servers were so friendly and our family felt right at home. We ordered pizza, which was delicious, and a Stromboli (also delicious) but our favorite was the Greek salad. Everything was so fresh and nothing about it was skimpy. Even my 3 year old could not get enough of the salad! ”
“ Calamari as an appetizer and Pizza lunch special; the best of both worlds! Reasonable pricing for the Cape. ”
“ I love the food and the pasta Alfredo was so good. When I got the pizza the cheese was perfect and the crust was crispy and cooked perfectly. ”
“ Showed up as they were closing, after coming in late by boat due to poor seas. They were kind enough to make us a pizza and salad to-go. Can't thank them enough for helping us out. On top of that the food was really good! ”
“ Great place: excellent pizza, great red sauce meals (chicken parm, baked shells, etc! ) and good steak sandwiches. Service incredibly friendly and welcoming . We first found after giving up on an unreasonable wait at a more famous seafood place nearby, and never looked back . We are already repeat customers and plan to continue. ”
“ THE place to stop before you get to your destination and unpack. The pizza is outstanding the best in Cape May. Friendly atmosphere. Had the chicken Alfredo which was great. Calamari and chicken wings also great. Reasonable prices. Nice view of the harbor as you enter Cape May from the parkway. ”
“ They have really good pizza. Came here since it was close to the dock for whale watching. It is an affordable place to eat. And the pizza was one of the best ive had. The place was clean and quite. They were open early. They also provided pizza on the boat we were in. I really like the location too. Its right by the water, just a short walk across the street. Will definitly come back if we ever in the area. ”